South Hayward United Methodist Church has two choirs that perform each Sunday for the worship service.  The Introit Choir is a small group that sings a variety of types of music and occasionally plays hand bells.  The Chancel Choir is a larger group that sings more traditional sacred music.  Every Easter and Christmas the choirs perform a cantata.  The Christmas play is an annual musical tradition that showcases the children of the church.

The Praise Team, a group of singers with instruments such as guitars, drums and piano,  leads the congregation in song before Sunday worship service.